
3 Keepers and a Regret is a recurring series on Retail Therapy on Substack where I ask people I admire to name 3 things they’d fight to keep — bought, inherited, stolen — and 1 thing they regret.

Grace McClure is the person on Substack who makes me snort. The most. Part shock: “Did she just say that?”
Part jealousy: “Why didn’t I think of that?”
And worse, if I had, would I have had the nerve to hit the post button? Or would I have softened the blow first?
That’s her Substack, Back to Shameless: the fight to be our true selves when the world keeps telling us we’re doing it wrong.
Three Keepers
3 things you’d fight to keep — bought, inherited, stolen
No. 1 — My engagement ring
As a packrat in recovery, and also a thrifter, I can say that I come across more than my fair share of retail gems. A ballerina’s collection of silk gloves? Check. A leather trench coat with fur trim and bleached-out pit stains on the liner? Check. A hand-painted Italian serving platter with paisley abstract shapes that feels both ’80s and current? Double check.
But for my top three keepers, I’d have to dig a little deeper.
At the risk of sounding basic or worse, romantic, I’d have to say my wedding ring set is a physical item I’d be devastated to lose. See what I did there? Set. This allowed me to sneak in a buy one, get one. My engagement ring is a Victorian cluster ring from the 1920s, and the band is a colourful gem ring my old neighbour made.
No. 2 — My travel memories
Secondly, I’d want to hold onto my travel memories. I did a semester abroad at a pivotal moment when I was fresh into becoming an adult. I was in my early twenties and had a debaucherous, rich time with new friends travelling all over Europe on Ryanair flights, and it really reshaped how I see the world. These trips, and my continued visits to Europe, Portugal in particular, make the world feel bigger and smaller all at once and always leave me with dozens of ideas for how I want to live next. And yes, they all involve wine.
No. 3 — the women who raised me
The last thing I want to keep is the influence of the great women who raised me. I come from a long line of strong matriarchs, funny people, “fuck ’em” people. They all encouraged individuality, creativity, and weren't afraid to stand out in a crowd.
They all made something great out of something small.
One Regret
now the regret
I guess I regret not buying Bitcoin when it was like $11 in 2013, and we knew about it? I worked alongside Silicon Valley tech nerds who'd been given Bitcoin at a party as a little gift bag gimmick. If I'd bought a few then, I certainly wouldn't be thrifting bras or buying fruits and veg off that depressing 50%-off rotten stand.
But then again, maybe unearned wealth would've turned me into an even more insufferable, inflated version of myself?


Why I’m Still Shopping
For too long I’ve been censoring myself. Call it the curse of corporate. Or the price of being really good at saying out loud the thing that some aren’t even comfortable thinking.
So finding someone like Grace who isn’t holding back is refreshing. But I also recognize the pattern. Poking at ourselves -- before someone else gets the chance to. Because the risk that comes with speaking up is real: you put a target on your back.
It’s easy to get taken down. Dodging it takes finesse, which isn’t my natural instinct. So I’ve had to learn to pivot. To hold my tongue. Or at least try to.
But I need people like Grace to remind me to stop over-thinking everything. Starting with the post button.
Thanks to Grace McClure of Back to Shameless
When life stops making sense, we shop post. More soon.



Other funny folks who’ve shared their 3 Keepers: Lucy Sweet, Vivian Manning-Schaffel & Jennie Egerdie










Grace’s notes make me laugh out loud too. I’m glad to hear that Portugal made an impression, as it’s the country I’ve called home for more than 12 years.
Rani, thank you for that make-my-chest-hurt level of kind intro. Loved seeing how this came together, and for the community you're creating. Great series, and so thrilled to be a part of it. Thank you!